Active Active   Unanswered Unanswered

One Less Lady on the Seas - A Tale of Tears

If it doesn't pertain to metal, wood, wire or fabric—but it is about vintage Chris-Crafts, ask your question or give your advice here.

Moderators: Don Ayers, Al Benton, Don Vogt

Post Reply
User avatar
campjer
Posts: 231
Joined: Tue Nov 27, 2007 11:52 am
Location: I'm from the sea.
Contact:

One Less Lady on the Seas - A Tale of Tears

Post by campjer » Wed Jun 22, 2011 6:07 pm

Hi Everyone,

It's been probably a year since I've been active in the forums... excuse my tardiness but I've been extremely busy in life and not enough with things that matter (like my mahogany ladies!). For those who were following my threads on the 1950 42' DCFB complete rebuild - she is still coming along but as always, became more involved than originally anticipated. Hopefully she'll be done by fall of this year. I also still have my 1961 32' Connie which I have the starboard side off of to replank before I sell her. Makes for a great treefort for my little nephews until then :).

I decided to move full time onto a boat this year come hell or high water. With my DCFB not going to be ready, I began searching around for a new acquisition. While I 'toyed' with the idea of picking up my boatrights 1966 44' Pacemaker (it's immaculate and still for sale!) I opted to purchase a 1960 45' Constellation on Lake Huron. I began looking at her in March or April and after initial inspection, I put down a deposit until the put in date which was May 13 or 14. The boat came with a survey from 2007 which was pretty decent (though I later learned of a 2nd survey which would've seen this entire story not occur).

Image

Trapped by a combination of events including learning of a faulty exhaust manifold, the biggest water spout I ever hope to see in my life...

Image

...and days of thick fog - I wound up living aboard her in Port Elgin, ON for three weeks (a beautiful town if you get to go - tell Peter or the lovely Katie I sent you!). I order my new manifold from Robert Henkel and kept it aboard deciding not to install it until it was necessary. Despite being told that the gas in both tanks was fresh from the previous fall - I also learned on a sea trial that the starboard tank was a combination of jelly and water. Sadly, the nearest company who would touch my situation was about 3hrs away and wanted more than $2000 to pump the tank. I made the decision to fill the port tank with new clean fuel, water remover and some octane booster then run both engines from the one tank.

Image


On June 1st we decided to make the journey. It was a bit of a windy day but the weather wasn't getting better. We spent about 5hrs trekking our way up the eastern shores of Lake Huron sitting atop large rollers in 45-60km/h winds. While it was a bit of a white-knuckler - the ship (branded Wood Works but my name was 'Temporary Solution') held strong until the weather subsided on the North Western gap of the Bruce Peninsula. We arrived in Tobermory, ON where we stayed for 2-nights enjoying many a pint at the one bar open prior to tourist season. It was here we found someone to pump our starboard tank. On June 3rd after 3hrs of pumping "crap" out of the tank - we pulled up to the fuel dock and I shook my wallet over the tank until full.


The weather was the best I had ever seen in my years of boating. Large open waters that were like glass. Pushing 13-15 knots at a comfortable 2500rpms on both engines, we discovered Flower Pot and Bears' Rump Islands - both fantastic sights if you get the opportunity to see them.


Image


It wasn't a long journey, but 3 or 4hrs after departing Tobermory we arrived in Lion's Head, Ontario... Our plan was simply to top up our tanks so that we could begin the trek across the mighty Georgian Bay. Little did I know that this port would be the last port my new love would ever see.


Pulling up to the fuel dock we quickly realized that the marina was closed. We were getting close to accepting that we'd be over-nighting here when a man who saw us in Tobermory waved to us as he was opening up the marina office. We told him we were after gas and while he didn't work there (he had in the past) he said he could help us out. "Great! Our journey is going to continue!", I thought.

We filled up the boat as I shook my wallet over the gas tanks for the 2nd time in a day then I turned on the blower motors and we walked away for 40-minutes to admire the awe-inspiring scenery and see all the prom kids getting their photos taken by the last manned light house on the entire Great Lakes System.

Once aboard my 1st Mate and I spent 15-20 minutes charting our next course. Our goal was to head East across Georgian Bay to the Trent Canal but we knew light wasn't on our side so we found a harbour on the map that was on the main waters (for those familiar with the area - you would be insane to navigate the head waters at dark).

What happened next is still un-explainable. I turned the starboard key and I don't honestly recall if it even turned over. My fleeting thought at the moment was "did running the blower for close to an hour drain the banks enough to not crank the engines?" - we had not been connected to shore power, but regardless - I dismissed this thought as soon as I had it. Reaching over - I then turned the port engine key. One or two clicks and in a millisecond - shaking houses up to 5-kilometres away - my poor baby exploded with a thunderous BANG!

Image

Image


It was the most terrifying and awesome experience I hope no one else ever has to go through. Though it happened so incredibly quick - my entire world stood still and I can only draw the analogy of the Matrix films, where suddenly time stops. I felt like I could reach out and grab any piece of debris - study it - then replace it at my own leisure. All while I was crossing my arms and turning to my right just as the Salon window to the helm came at me in an entire sheet. The fireball followed closely behind and I attribute the sheet of glass to deflecting the fireball so that neither my cousin nor I were scorched.

The next thing I remember was that I was at the very back of the aft deck on my stomach. I opened my eyes to see the same terrified look in my cousins' face as he opened his. With the vessel now listing greatly to port side, I looked into him and yelled "JUMP DERRICK - RUN RUN RUN". I have absolutely no recollection of actually getting off the boat... although we would have had to have jumped down 6-7 ft. to the gas dock then run up a 30' steel ramp to the parking lot. My next memory was being on land and screaming for everyone to run away from it (knowing we had 1200-1400 litres of fuel on board and we were parked beside the fuel docks).


Image


A secondary explosion did occur which I later attributed to a small propane cylinder for the barbecue going up.

The entire marina population as well as several cottages nearby were evacuated as the volunteer fire department took control of the situation. You can read more about that here (article inaccuracies: the boat sank in 20' of water, not 40' - and at no time did any gas tank explode):

http://www.owensoundsuntimes.com/Articl ... &e=3156188


While our physical injuries were minor - I'm sure the mental trauma will last for years to come. We are both safe boaters with years of experience on the water... my 1st Mate also being an Auxiliary Coast Guard member just west of Toronto, ON.

The following day in the late afternoon, my baby was raised from the waters of Georgian Bay to the eyes of hundreds of onlookers after a 7hr effort by several people. It was extremely painful to watch her come up then be loaded on a trailer and towed to the local dump - but I stood watching hoping it would help my own healing process.

We still don't have a cause as to what happened as the government is investigating which could mean several months. Obviously people speculate about this and that - but I'm not speculating at all... just looking forward to reading the final report.

Aside from being in the market for a new ship (ideally in the Toronto area)... my main purpose of posting aside from entertainment purposes is this (not to draw any inferences from anything): for those of us selling a vessel - please do the absolute right thing by giving full disclosure on the boat. Obviously everyone wants to make their money - but money is not worth life and/or limb - yours or your potential buyer. Aside from the second survey mentioned above, I've since learned other things about this ship (post-disaster) that would've seen me not buy her in the first place and although my cousin and I are (thankfully) alive and not very physically messed-up by this tragedy the fact is we could have been. We could have been very very badly injured or killed. Full disclosure (at least in Ontario/Canada) is required BY LAW and failure to do so is a chargeable criminal offence. I hope that by people reading this, if one person is honest about their vessel to a potential buyer and it saves a life - then none of this is in vein.

Here's the last video of us pulling into Lion's Head. Also the last video of this boat in it's former glory ever. My cousin was at the helm and his final docking of this lady was impeccable.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3e1xLl-3y9A


Happy and SAFE boating to all my friends and everyone else on the Chris Craft Forums. I'll be spending some time now working on my '61 32' Connie and hopefully even more time on my '50 42' DCFB for therapy :).

Best,
Jeremy Campbell
Cheers,
Jeremy Campbell

Current Projects:
'61 32' Connie
'61 45' Connie (RIP)
'50 42' DCFB

Wet Dreams:
'61 57' Connie

User avatar
Chad Durren
Posts: 666
Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2006 1:39 pm
Location: Chicago, Illinois
Contact:

Post by Chad Durren » Wed Jun 22, 2011 6:36 pm

Holy Sh_t!

I'm glad no one was hurt. Sorry to hear about your loss.
1952 CC 18' Sportsman
1969 CC 19' Commander Super Sport

User avatar
57 chris
Posts: 861
Joined: Sat Jan 05, 2008 2:43 pm
Location: Churchville, NY

Post by 57 chris » Wed Jun 22, 2011 7:20 pm

Jeremy,
I can't even begin to express the sadness I feel for your loss.
I am so glad that you survived this horrific event.
Don't give up the faith, not that it will bring the boat back but hopefully the accident report will uncover the cause of this so it may spare others this agony.

Craig
1957 18' SeaSkiff #SK 18675 "Knot Sure!"
1958 18' SeaSkiff #SK18722 "Wreckreation"

Past projects: 1972 19' Lancer with 307 Volvo drive-Great Blue, 1968 23' Lancer Offshore with 283 Volvo drive-Narwahl
1988 FourWinns 245 Vista - Blue Ayes.

It's good to have wood!

User avatar
Bill Basler
Posts: 1996
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2005 4:48 pm
Location: Cedar Rapids, IA

Post by Bill Basler » Wed Jun 22, 2011 7:49 pm

Jeremy, wow. This sent a chill up my spine. Even more so given it sounds as though you did your part. I am so sorry to hear this but extremely thankful we are not reading an obituary.

Your most recent Brass Bell includes a feature story, titled simply, "Explosion." This article is timely and equally as horrifying. As in your situation, all of the safety checks were followed. The root cause of the explosion was not one that I would have guessed, but in hindsight, after reading the article, it makes perfect sense.

I am sorry to hear of your loss, but very thankful you are here to tell us all about it.
Bill Basler

User avatar
mfine
Posts: 1405
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2010 8:16 pm
Location: Pittsford and Penn Yan NY

Post by mfine » Wed Jun 22, 2011 7:56 pm

Glad to hear injuries were minor.

Lift and Sniff. Always. Blower systems can fail or they can be overwelmed by a bilge full of fuel. Modern crap gas with ethanol will evaporate even faster than the old stuff so with enough surface area from a big leak, no blower will keep up.

User avatar
RRGadow
Posts: 506
Joined: Mon Nov 30, 2009 8:55 pm
Location: Durham, NC
Contact:

Post by RRGadow » Wed Jun 22, 2011 9:53 pm

wow...what a horrible story! Glad you lived to tell us about it!
www.Gadowguitars.com

Varnish addiction.

User avatar
Al Benton
Club Executive Team
Posts: 3549
Joined: Thu Oct 27, 2005 3:41 pm
Location: St. Louis, MO

Post by Al Benton » Thu Jun 23, 2011 12:14 am

Jeremy,

First, thank God that you and your cousin are OK following this horrific explosion, fire and eventual loss of your cruiser. Thanks for your very vivid description of the incident.

It's not fair to try to analyze the cause without knowing more about it. It was likely gas fumes in the bilge, whether propane or gasoline. The investigation will hopefully find a likely cause for the explosion.

Although I am quite frequently quoting the "Lift & Sniff" routine here on Boat Buzz it may not have revealed an alarming condition if fuel or propane was collecting under the sole of the salon (or possibly propane gas in the salon???). Maybe to be totally paranoid, we need to check out more than the just the engine compartment on large cruisers. Who knows???

Bottom line is you both survived without serious injuries and are willing to share your story, for which we are thankful here on Boat Buzz. I and others here will continue to advocate "Lift & Sniff" and may extend this include possible unlikely places on these larger cruisers.

Thanks very much for sharing your story.

Al

User avatar
Ken Miller
Posts: 301
Joined: Wed Jun 18, 2008 9:05 pm
Location: Northwest Georgia

Post by Ken Miller » Thu Jun 23, 2011 5:20 am

Jeremy,

As Al said, thank God you are both okay. I had noticed the absence of your posts in the forum. Wondered why, as you were a consistent/frequent part of the on-line dialogue. I've always enjoyed hearing what you had to contribute to the conversations and enjoyed your Youtube videos. Glad to hear you are okay and to see you back. Take care.



Ken Miller.
1951 Chris Craft U-22-1705 "Miss Cynthia"

User avatar
campjer
Posts: 231
Joined: Tue Nov 27, 2007 11:52 am
Location: I'm from the sea.
Contact:

Post by campjer » Thu Jun 23, 2011 7:24 am

Thanks for all the condolences. I'm definitely happy to have come out mostly unscathed - a lot of that having to do with the compassion and humor injected into me by the fine people of Lion's Head - where I stayed for just over a week while the onsite investigation was moving forward.

Again - while I can't and won't speculate about causes as it's under investigation, I can state that the only propane on board was the small camping size cylinder I mentioned. There were no propane appliances nor was the alcohol stove ever employed in the 3-weeks that I was in possession of the vessel.

Bill: I'm looking forward to reading the new article both for pure interest and to pass along to the Fire Marshall's Office. Also - while I need to do an inventory, I seemed to have lost most of my collection of The Brass Bell which I so proudly displayed for guests aboard. Once I find out which ones perished - can I submit a list to you for purchasing (assuming inventory of any still exist?).

Al: I don't think it would be over-paranoid to do a manual 'Sniff' of all compartments prior to starting up. In fact, I'm sure for me anyways, this is going to become ingrained in my processes.


Here are some videos off the Bruce Peninsula on the day of the explosion:

Cutting Port into Flower Pot Island:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ojn6LWaYLjA

Looking at wake from stern:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=szNUYwyWkWc

Looking at wake from starboard aft:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YaE-6ENoGb0

Bluffs of Lion's Head:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZQQP1VD1LZM


Here are some more pics:

Image


Image


Image


Image


Image


Image


Image
Cheers,
Jeremy Campbell

Current Projects:
'61 32' Connie
'61 45' Connie (RIP)
'50 42' DCFB

Wet Dreams:
'61 57' Connie

jahearne
Posts: 423
Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2008 4:31 pm
Location: San Francisco

Post by jahearne » Thu Jun 23, 2011 1:29 pm

I am so glad you & your cousin are still around to tell the story. There will always be another boat...
John & Wendy

kcupido
Posts: 106
Joined: Wed Oct 24, 2007 9:54 am
Location: Sault Ste. Marie, ON

Post by kcupido » Thu Jun 23, 2011 2:18 pm

J,
What can be said when we lose a part of the family? Made me stop and think about each time I got behind the wheel to get under way.
Accidents can happen in a blink of an eye.
Glad you made it out alive!

User avatar
Al Benton
Club Executive Team
Posts: 3549
Joined: Thu Oct 27, 2005 3:41 pm
Location: St. Louis, MO

Post by Al Benton » Thu Jun 23, 2011 2:41 pm

Jeremy,

Thanks for all the videos, what an incredibly beautiful place to go cruising! Although it's not possible to forget the bad memories that followed this cruise, please keep the good ones first and foremost in your memories.

Wow, the aftermath photos are a solid reminder of just how blessed you and your cousin are to have survived this ordeal with only minor injuries. Now as you count your many blessings you have a big one to be thankful for!

Al

User avatar
BrokenRule2
Posts: 294
Joined: Tue Jun 02, 2009 8:56 pm
Location: North California Delta
Contact:

Post by BrokenRule2 » Fri Jun 24, 2011 10:18 am

WOW, glad you all are OK. I will have these images in my head as I turn the key on our boat. Good thing no one was down below!

Mike

Rugger8
Posts: 318
Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2008 2:40 pm
Location: Dutchtown, NY

Post by Rugger8 » Wed Jun 29, 2011 8:57 pm

Jeremy,

I am truly sorry to hear what happened to you and your boat. But I do thank all the powers that be that managed to keep you safe. There is always another boat!

Hope to see you next time I am in town!

Jeff

aliwildatwork
Posts: 284
Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2010 7:00 am
Location: Atlanta

Post by aliwildatwork » Thu Jun 30, 2011 6:02 am

I can't even begin to express how grateful and horrified I am for you. Thank you and the powers that be that the two of you are all right! I had a similar experience on my 69 VW bus (no blowers) but a full tank of gas and flames 30 feet high when she went...it took 13 minutes for the fire trucks to get there and needless to say there was nothing left to save. The one thing I learned was that full tanks don't explode, they are more likely to explode when they are empty..the vacuum or something.
I also appreciate your humor, it's honest and well deserved. Thanks for sharing it with us all.

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests